English-Only

Texas State Rep. Betty Brown asks Asians why they can't have names like hers

This came right out of the mouth of a Betty Brown who couldn't for the life of her understand why Koreans and Chinese constituents insisted in making her life difficult with their not-in-English names. From Texas lawmaker suggests Asians adopt easier names :: Houston Chronicle:

"Rather than everyone here having to learn Chinese-- I understand it's a rather difficult language -- do you think that it would behoove you and your citizens to adopt a name that we could deal with more readily here"

Rep Betty Brown

Arrogant idiots like Rep. Betty Brown have the nerve to suggest we go back to a time when English language tests were used by racists and bigots everywhere in the United States as a way to disenfranchise millions of non-English speaking Americans citizens, particularly Puerto Ricans.

You know, because people who don't speak English for one reason or another can't have the right to vote.

You know, because it's just not possible that the United States may be technically a bilingual country thanks to that little colony they keep in the Caribbean called Puerto Rico.

Yet what is shocking is this woman's complete lack of understanding of the laws of the land: It is illegal to deny voting rights to any US citizen regardless of their language dominance.

My mother who is a white Puerto Rican woman was told the same thing over 45 years ago when she tried to vote for the first time in the United States. As a Puerto Rican, she is a full citizen and yet was treated as if she were an "illegal immigrant". It's not just that we have a separate culture, the language was a huge issue. For a lower-class white Puerto Rican woman it meant being barred from colleges and literally pushed to work in sweat shops and work herself from the bottom until she could command the language.

Yet we Puerto Ricans are political animals and my mother was inspired by Kennedy, an Irish-Catholic who kinofsortof sold himself to Latino communities as an "immigrant in his own land". When she went to register to vote for the first time, the woman looked at her and said something to the effect that, since she was a white woman anyway, why keep her spic-sounding name. It was because of this experience that my mother not only was hell bent on voting, but became a civil and voting rights activist.

Someday I'll write my mother's story so you can understand the year gaps in what am about to say. My mother met back in the 1960s the guy who helped write the "Puerto Rican Amendment" to the Voting Rights Act. It took her almost 40 years for my to marry Gilberto Gerena Valentín. Although am kind of old for the term, he's technically now my stepfather --and ironically the man who introduced my mother to my father.

Yes, my life is like a friggin' telenovela; but back to the topic at hand.

The Voting Rights Act was amended exactly so that misguided linguists and bigots alike could not claim "but this isn't about race" and still discriminate against non-English speaking minorities. In effect, "linguistic minority" was coined as a way to point to language, not ethnicity nor race as the motive for exclusion. As Gerena tells me, the reason why this was called "The Puerto Rican" and not the "Hispanic" or the "Mexican-American" amendment was simple: New York City had a patter of not just chasing Puerto Ricans away from the voting booths but of "spontaneous" apartment fires, evictions and even imprisonment in districts with heavy Puerto Rican populations. Bobby Kennedy, who had integrated the Attoney General's Office during his tenure, understood the power of this constituency. As US Senator, along with Jacob Javits, they introduced this measure in Washington not only as a shrewd move in minority politics but because tactically, it was a genius : You had full American citizens who, instead of being discriminated by race proved that discrimination was rampant in northern states ALSO based on language.

From :

Section 4(e)cases led to the recapture of three counties in New York City under Section 5 of the Act – forcing the City to prove that all future changes would not discriminate. Section 4(e)cases also allowed the Mexican American Legal Defense Fund to convince Congress in1975 that English only election systems were just as exclusive as other tests for voting inthe Deep South. And Section 4(e) cases showed the country that if bilingual electionscould work for Boricuas in New York City – the biggest city in the U.S. – they could work anywhere. This led to the bilingual elections for all Latinos, and Asian Americansand Native Americans as well.Forty years ago Puerto Ricans demanded that Congress protect their right to vote againstpolitical interests that excluded them from realizing their full political strength.Democracy in New York and in the United States has been more open and improved ever since.

That this woman, with one of the largest Mexican-American voting blocks in the nation doesn't know it's illegal to even hint at denying the right to vote to US citizens who don't speak English is amazing to me. So here's the text from the "Puerto Rican Amendment" to the Voting Rights Act of 1965. She needs to get schooled:
 more this way»

liza's picture



Check Out "5 English Lessons From the Anti-Immigrant Movement"

Kyle has compiled a whole collection of images from white supremacist rallies against immigrants. Here's the lede:

The Sanctuary:: 5 English Lessons From the Anti-Immigrant Movement: "Any nativist will tell you that polls show 1,000% of 'Mericans support speaking only English in the United States of America. It doesn't matter if the U.S. can't even understand the languages of the countries it goes to war with (you don't need to understand people to shoot at them). If people can't speak English like they're supposed to, they're not real 'Mericans.

Using this iron-clad logic, I thought I'd compile a list of five English lessons for those that want to learn to how to be a real 'Merican and speak English."

The results are HYSTERICAL. Go see the whole collection, NOW!

(Via The Sanctuary:: 5 English Lessons From the Anti-Immigrant Movement.)

liza's picture



Dear Univision, You sucked un poquito


Photo courtesy of Univisión

I am so glad I didn't go to Miami for this :

Reporters who didn't speak Spanish were already anxious about the translation devices that didn't quite fit in our ears. (Porque soy de California, yo hablo un poquito Espanol.)

But 90 seconds before the forum began tonight, the Media Room had no sound - not in Spanish, English or French. Nada.

Spanish- and English-speaking reporters in the room erupted in a panic, sending University of Miami staff scrambling to try and fix the feed. What most reporters heard for the first 16 minutes of the debate was static - both from the closed television feed and from the translation device.

Even Sen. Barack Obama (D-Ill.) seemed to have trouble, yanking the earpiece from his ear mid-way through his answer to a question on Iraq.

Notwithstanding the awe inspiring set and the hard hitting tonality of the questioning, I don't think that Univision did anything groundbreaking. On the contrary, by not allowing Dodd and Richardson to respond in Spanish, they pandered to the Democrats who still treat latinos as a political ghetto from where to get voting servants to work for their "mainstream" agendas.

Richardson complained, and with good reason, about not being able to speak in Spanish. Hillary, Obama, Edwards, they need to get over it. Spanish is the official second language of the United States, thanks in part to that little colony nobody ever mentions in these forums anyway, Puerto Rico. If they couldn't deal with it, then their muscling in the “English-only” requirement for the forum should be used against them at the voting booth.
 more this way»

liza's picture



Syndicate content

User login

The Publisher
Liza Sabater

Daily servings of political dissent
culturekitchen

Grassroots News and
Activism for New Yorkers

Daily Gotham

Feminist Bloggers
Network

BlogSheroes

A new kind of vouyerism
Voogling

Art + Code + Philosophy
Potatoland.blog

Got any dirt, tips, leads or money for us? Then drop us a line or two at editors [at] culturekitchen [dot] com or use our general contact form to reach everybody in the editorial team ASAP.

Nibble daily on our brainy goodness with our daily syndication digest. You'll receive an email with a list and links to the previous day's posts.



Powered by FeedBlitz

Upcoming events

  • No upcoming events available

QUOTES


[P]overty in the world is an artificial creation. It doesn't belong to human civilization, and we can change that, we can make people come out of poverty and have the real state of affairs. So the only thing we have to do is to redesign our institutions and policies, and there will be no people who will be suffering from poverty. So I would hope that this award will make this message heard many times, and in a kind of forceful way, so that people start believing that we can create a poverty-free world. That's what I would like to do.

— Muhammad Yunus
Interviewed by NobelPrize.org

Poll