I have been inundated with these annoying, anonymous chain e-mails stating that Whitefolk are trying to sabotage Jamie Foxx's upcoming music show because he refused to put token white performers on the roster. And to foil the success of his show due to his insolent Black pride, they've purposely put him up against 'American Idol'. Is this true? Was Foxx acting with conviction or with racial malice? And regardless, so what? After all, of all the things to clog up my inbox with, why moral outrage regarding a televised music show, of the kind that Blackfolk have been disproportionately visible for years? Why is this what people have chosen to be up in arms about and leveraging the Internet to advocate for versus, say, Darfur, Haiti, Katrina, political corruption, corporate greed, the fight for a living wage, etc., etc.?
Regardless of where you come down on any of these issues, it is quite revealing how and why people respond to media-amplified and -skewed issues -- particularly when laced with race.
Do I think folks are kinda missing the point when they choose to carelessly and thoughtlessly forward unsubstantiated information about something as benign as a televised music show? Absolutely. But as my grandmother always used to posit: "If you're Black and not paranoid, you're crazy."
agree and disagree
Well, again, I agree and disagree. As you say, the most important thing is to agree that we both want to see a viable solution.
Regarding your last point about tree planting. My training was in Soil Science - which is probably about as far as you can get from selling Palestinian textiles! It is undeniably true that Israelis have done amazing things with scarce natural resources. On the other hand, the agricultural systems that have developed are very dependent on irrigation. And, I am sorry to say that the evidence suggests that much of the irrigation water needed, particularly in the settlements, is taken at the expense of Palestinians.
Simply planting trees without considering the wider environmental and social context is no solution in itself. There must be justice and parity even in this.
Regarding the rest of your post, I would agree that we need the flexibility to hold loosely to our ideals. To be honest, it is not me you [ie pro-Israelis] need to convince. Palestinians have lost hope, when you speak to them often their eyes gloss over and they look dejectedly at the floor. They cannot cope with more fine words from their own leaders, the Israelis or the rest of the world. They just want to see their lives improving. This is why we started trading directly with Palestinian businesses, tried to do the things that others said was impossible or irresponsible.
Having only briefly been to Tel Aviv, I can't tell you what the feeling is there.