Are You Dog-Faced or Downright Hang-Dog for Memorial Day?
Are you gung-ho Marine Corps dog-face for Memorial Day, or just hangdog, as in depressed and demoralized? Favorite Daughter has been thinking about this in her drought-parched Hammock of Death:
"Of (Puppy) Dogs and Marines" by Favorite Daughter
There's a little girl who lives next door to me, about 5, and fully capable of walking and talking and waving to me on occasion, which is always mind-blowing because I remember her family moving in prior to her existence.
The family is, I guess, a good one, at least in the traditional American sense. They have a yard with nice grass and a back deck, an easy southern drawl on the rare occasions I hear them speak. They play country music on the radio on the weekend, host some sort of church get-together on Wednesday nights. They possess a comfortable façade of Americana, which I'm sure I could peel back quite easily, revealing a healthy amount of sordidness, but I won't.
They also have the meanest dog I've ever met.
He's a Boston Terrier, a breed second only to the pug in its tenacious ugliness. He despises me even more than he despises the rest of the world; whenever we're outside together, he runs to the edge of his yard and threatens me in every way he can. He once chased a garbage man up a brick mailbox.
But today, as I tried to relax in my backyard, swinging languidly in my Hammock of Death--long story--I became aware of the little girl next door.
"That's MY soccer ball," I heard her say to someone in an imperious voice that sounded suspiciously like my own. "That's not YOUR soccer ball!"
I realized she was talking to the dog, and looked up just in time to see her pick him up, pull him to her, and lug him from one end of her yard to the other.
The weirdest thing was that the dog wasn't angry, snarling, incensed as he is at the very sight of me. He was docile, even a little nonplussed -- ho-hum, my girl is picking me up again, what a blessing I don't have to walk.
And it got me thinking: What may be a hideously mean and ugly attack dog to one person may be somebody else's puppy. Once this thought entered my head, of course, it rolled around and marinated itself, seemingly at random, with other thoughts from earlier in the week.
Wednesday, I made the mistake of watching the 10 o'clock news, and caught a sad local interest story. You know the one I mean, it runs on local stations everywhere now. A hometown boy who graduated from the same high school as your boss' son, knows all the good places to eat, like you, not like the college students who aren't from here and think they know everything even though they never leave downtown. He became a marine, and now he's dead, mortar shell or something to the heart. And he was only 21 years old, and he left behind a wife and baby.
I've never really been anti-war, not that I'm intent on "staying the course" or anything either. I figure that I don't know anything about fighting a war, or even the middle east, and I try, as a rule, not to wax rhapsodic on topics I can't discuss with some degree of education. So I'm not going to really have an anti-war moment now.
I'm kind of with A.J. Soprano on this one -- he's been studying the middle east conflict this season. While not assigning blame, he's wondering: How can you not be depressed? How can you wake up in the morning knowing that all this is going on in the world and keep going day after day?
What the hell is wrong with us (and here I mean ALL of us, the human race at large) that we can justify taking someone else's life? Is oil a reason? Is the fact that we disagree on what (imaginary) sentient being controls the universe a reason? What kind of bullshit reasons are those? When you get right down to it, is anything an excuse? Is there ever a good enough reason to take a life for a principle, to look at a person in front of you, and forget that maybe he's someone's husband? Someone's child? Someone's father?
Hell. He could even be somebody's puppy.
Depression | Identity | Marines | Memorial Day | Perspective | War | AJ Soprano | Favorite Daughter
Copying what I just
posted over at Cocking A Snook:
I’m not up to depressed and demoralized yet. I’m still at pissed off.
I am angry with what passes for Democratic leadership and frustrated that all we seem to have in this area this weekend is a bunch of flag waving “we love the troops†crap.
Where’s a good peace march when you need one!
Nance
"Biting" humor
with or without the dogs is more my style for coping with life and death, preferably cerebral rather than what I used to call "juvenile" but --because Favorite Daughter's humor is in fact from a teen but far from juvenile--now merely call "bathroom" humor.
So for the antiwar sensibility, my own protesting would be more Catch 22 or M*A*S*H, power of story with some cathartic laughs. I guess it runs in the family?
Although my dad was a Korean Conflict veteran and retired Air Force Colonel . . . I cracked silly jokes after his funeral that had my little sister helplessly laughing for hours, at a Cracker Barrel appropriately enough--puns aren't that ha-ha funny but at least they ARE cerebral. 
And he was definitely never about public displays of emotion, through protesting or even having a birthday party. He was deferential to others, circumspect, fastidious and quite the courtly officer and gentleman both in public and private. I don't usually memorialize him in that role on Memorial Day (or any other time) but now y'all have me connecting it, kinda wishing I could hear him marvel at all-grown-up Favorite Daughter's good-humored (but hardly fastidious!) way of seeing and coping with the world . . .
Apropo of Memorial Day, I rewrote my will
There's not that much to give away, and if I don't check out soon, there may not be that much. But the bank made me do it. As happens, the bank changed hands and this time they do not want to be my executor. The attorney suggested I asked friends. I love my friends and feared they would turn on me if they knew they'd have to clear out this ratpack's nest. However, I asked and they said they'd be honored. So I invited the two (one is alternative) Near Sixties to lunch to let them know how much it means to me. One friend drove me to the restaurant in a red convertible (Ford) and the other home (also red but GM). They hugged each other before I could introduce them and then proceeded to check out medical insurance options, pre-Medicare. From there to children, past marriages and a good sprinkling of what's wrong with Bush, at which time I got to talk a little. I feel so loved.
Also there is real responsibility. This weekend I've spent time clearing out old records and tomorrow morning my teenage buddy is coming to put stuff on the top cupboard shelves where I will never have to think of using them again. Already I have been relieved of a stuffed chair I wished I hadn't brought to the apartment and one nice colander. If lucky, maybe the mother of my buddy will take the oversized crock pot.
Well, I just wanted to let you know that I am anxious to get busier on important things. This afternoon one blogge, not on CK, outlined the direct line between Jerry Falwell's satanic ways and the state of the nation. And another did a reasonably good job of convincing us that Bush was a psychopath. I felt so mellow and wrote what I thought would be comforting replies. It wouldn't have been possible if I hadn't listened to an hour's conversation between Bill Moyers and Maxine Hong Kingston regarding her work with disturbed returning veterans. She's a joy to listen to.
And that's the way I did the weekend, except of course I had to watch the memorial program live from the Capitol.
I'm sure you are having a good weekend. About the dog! Who knows?
Hi Margaret
Sounds like you are in good humor too. 
Favorite Daughter is not insensitive to death, of course. I didn't mean to leave that impression. But the closest she has come to it personally has to do with love, not war. She wrote (and cried and laughed) after her beloved dance teacher died in December.
And then blogged, natch.
"For life's not a paragraph and death, I think, is no parenthesis":
Jules showed up after awhile, we all cried ourselves out until we were completely dehydrated, then we started laughing. Because that is what you have to do. . .
"Good" deaths and not
It is a confusing "holiday." There are the people who died after a full life and are celebrated for having spent a part of their youth fighting a good fight. And there are the people who died during that good fight. They are honored. And there are the people who are dead and will be dead because of the current stupidity. They are honored. But the war itself is an evil that should not have been imposed on them and their families. And that colors the acts of honoring.
We hung the flag at half-mast this morning. After I mended it -- no rain but the wind tears everything up. And that's fine. We mean to honor the fallen and the rest who serve. But we hope that our neighbors do not mistake our flag for any show of support for this President or his obscene behavior.
And, yes, we are doing all the other things that need to be done. Yes, I know it's hard to not enjoy a sunny day of BBQing or a night out with friends. My errands need to be run like everyone else's. My kids have the sleepover tonight. Brownies must be baked! I want them to enjoy this day and every other day. I don't want them to know, really know, first hand, about death through war. Or love, for that matter. But that happens. We grieve. We grow.
But to have it thrust upon us for no good or natural reason. . . that's what has me continuing to be angry. The dying is not over. The life-altering injuries have not stopped. The families and this country are still being damaged by this insane war. And for absolutely no good, or even understandable or somehow comforting, reason.
I'm glad we're all having a good Memorial Day. Underneath it all though, and not so underneath, I am angry.
Nance
How About 9-11 Victims?
Nance, I've been completely out of the national news and commentary loop lately so I don't have any idea -- are nine-eleven victims included in this memorializing of war dead too, or are deaths of non-warriors in warfare (at home or abroad) in some other memorial category?
I don't know
Civilians die in military conflicts. Count them, don't count them, only count them if they are from your country?
Nance
People die. They deserve notice.
An hour of entertainment seems like short changing those who die. Victim of war, accident (natural and manmade), combatant, "non-combatant in a war zone," and more. Who gets the gold stars when a soldier's widow loses a child to poverty after the father's death? There are many ripple effects from war fatalities, regardless of whether the war was just. I personally do not ascribe to the "just war" theme.
In WWII, the real travesty was in a bungled conclusion to WWI. Was Viet Nam started because the Korean War is still not settled? We have Iraq I and Iraq II. And this is just reference to conflicts since the mother of our battles in the US. I'm reading the second volume of Branch Taylor's King-years series. Even in erudite venues like CK, there are those who are defining and pontificating over the "race issue." And some are defining holocaust. Darfur, Hitler's Germany, Tamil Tigers, whoever. There's a lot of memorializing to think about.
Last night at the Capitol the tone was quite different from the previous few years. In the past, living military played a bigger part. This time there was a chance to recognize the living wounded, the newly killed, and families whose lives have changed. Two ways of looking at this. Sober acknowledgment of war's high cost, or a propaganda ploy to allow Congress to accept more wars. Take your pick. I am so anti-war that I have studied it all my life. At this moment in Taylor I'm reading how LBJ twists arms to get the voting rights bill and Great Society legislation. To those who maybe weren't even born in 64, LBJ was known as the fellow who sent so many to their graves for no good reason.
It keeps me at the keyboard, hoping some of the young will realize they cannot conquer such a useless endeavor by ignoring reality. Studying war is bigger than politics, religion and patriotism. When citizens make their religion their politics, or their politics their religion, we are headed for a shallow nationalism which makes flagwaving pass for loyalty and memorials pass for human understanding.
I personally do not ascribe
I personally do not ascribe to the "just war" theme.
***
It's a tough call, no doubt. I think we can certainly recognize an "unjust" war when we see one though.
Nance































Just a Bite More
This afternoon after she had posted her war meditation, Favorite Daughter remembered a very funny (because it's so realistic!) Barbara Hamby poem, "St. Barbara of the Dog Bite" and read it out loud to me, doing all the accents and voices in a pitched chortle.
You won't be able to hear it as I did, too bad for you! -- but it's from Hamby's Delirium collection if you can find yourself a copy, and here's a taste: