Not Necessarily Wacko: Even If You DO Homeschool and Pray

As I continue to work through the whole god-guns-government culture being tied to home education (and vice versa) I found this cultural commentary:

Egalitarianism and Homeschooling-

One Member’s Personal Story by Karen Till

. . .The homeschool community is a culture, religion—to some a cult—in itself. I loved many aspects but certain things were hard to understand. For example, many people thought women should dress very modestly and with head coverings. Definitely the more “earthy” you were the better: grind your own grain, natural foods, bake your own bread.

Many also believed that couples should let God plan their family – and I mean no interference on your part—because it showed you had more faith. Moms should stay at home while dads provided for the family. All of these were what proved you were a godly woman. Of course, you needed to do this all with great delight and in an organized fashion.

I began to have difficulty with this culture as our children got older and their gender roles began to be more defined. . .I started to feel pressure about how my kids behaved and what they wore. We were not a family that believed that girls must wear dresses, but many of our friends did.

Then the whole courtship idea started bouncing around. . . Courtship in many ways seemed like a patriarchal concept.

The pressure got more and more intense and I resisted. I began to question and see flaws in this thinking. . .

I still believe in homeschooling, although I do not fit in with most in the community. I have discontinued much of my contact with the other women because it is too difficult. . . I felt like I couldn’t, and didn’t want to, measure up to their expectations of what kind of a woman I should be.

Our church has become a safe place for me and I love the changes and growth the community has made. I would say we are an emerging church and that concept thrills me as much as the equality issue does.

I love that the sides of the box have been blown off. My journey is so much more than I ever dreamed . . .

Most people in the homeschool community are traditional and patriarchal and I was embarrassed to be lumped together with them. I do believe that egalitarian views and homeschooling can co-exist. However it is not the norm. If you know people that are homeschooling please do not write them off . . .While some home educators are definitely closed to the idea of equality and freedom from subordination, you never know—God can get our attention in unexpected ways.

Things have evolved in our journey in this issue—for me I continue to learn and love all that I am finding out about biblical equality.

(thanks to A Dem Fine Woman for the connection)


JJ Ross's picture

| | | | | | | |

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
ParentCoach's picture

I agree that you can't lump all homeschool

children or parents together into the culture of guns, god, and george(bush). I am in home therapist to autistic children, and one of the things I do is develop and implement teaching strategies and curriculum for the homeschooled autistic child. A few of my clients are typical children who for one reason or another, are being homeschooled. All of my clients' parents are well-edcuated, liberal, and a number of them don't do the "Little Red Hen" routine at all.

I also know a fair number of pagan parents who choose to unschool or homeschool their children. I understand from your post you attend a church, however, if you are looking for more egalitarian homeschool community which is accepting of all faiths,(pagans don't believe in proselytizing at all, in our view, each path or non-path is as valid as the one we have chosen) may suggest you do a web search for pagan parents who are homeschooling?

Good luck.


JJ Ross's picture

And don't forget Buddhists

of whom there are many spiritually attuned homeschoolers, too! Smiling


JJ Ross's picture

For Me It's All Power of Story

and that's best written privately and personally, not by committee and most certainly not by governmental or neighborhood condo committee.

I don't go to church myself, no -- that was the woman whose blogpost I was highlighting. I think my biggest draw is to the concept of "collective consciousness" and that will continue to fascinate me, trying to figure out more about it before I slip the mortal coil. Deep thought akin to meditation, feeling connected to other living creatures as beings -- did the word creatures come from "created" though, oh dear!

The idea of "worship" and "prayer" though, any sort of mysticism, or intercession by men for other men who otherwise are at odds with the divine, is something that never really fit me.

OTOH, I don't like being subject to nature all that much either, having survived some nasty hurricanes and tornados, etc. in my lifetime, a car crash and nearly losing a child to drowning . . .so paganism may not be for me. I'm actually more of a cerebral CS Lewis type; I can and do wax rhapsodic about spiritual academics, understand and see value in almost any faith's power of story. Just don't ask me to pick one and reject all the rest! Smiling


NanceConfer's picture

Whew!

I was afraid I was going to have to start packing the kids up for church on Sunday. Or public school on Monday. Smiling

But we can be both heathens AND unschoolers? Fantastic!

Of course, this is a stereotype that many of us have struggled against. As a prominent unschooler recently posted, ". . . not all schoolkids are universally the same either."

Yep. Ruthlessly out of context. Sort of. It was in the context of a discussion about unschooling and teens and how nice her son is and how a lot of unschooled teens are nicer than we sometimes expect from teens and it was a concession that even some publicly schooled kids are decent human beings.

Wadda ya know. There's no magic wand no matter what choices a parent makes.

Maybe if we all became parents at about . . . what age, when do we think we've got a handle on being decent human beings ourselves? Age 60? 70? When do we finish sorting out how to be good enough people to be responsible for the well-being of another human being? To have enough self-discipline not to take our failings out on someone else in our care? To have enough self-respect to truly live with respect toward our own sometimes annoying and less-than-perfect children?

Nance


JJ Ross's picture

Heathen Unschooling?

The word "heathen" for unschooling seems ripe for playing with. Maybe "hearthens" -- meaning hearth in the practical private sense of being home/family centered rather than institutionally subservient to School, Church and State?

But no, some televangelist and wife would counter that it should be pronounced heart-hens, meaning the ruffly aproned homemaker feminissimo . . .never mind!


Summer M's picture

In many areas there are a

In many areas there are a lot of families who do homeschool for strong religious reasons, I know where I live all of the local groups are made of the kind of women described above. But that does not mean that all homeschoolers are like that, or even that all Christian homeschoolers are. One of the coolest homeschoolers I know is a pastor's wife, who certainly does not fit the stereotypical role at all. There are many homeschoolers out there from all kinds of backgrounds and walks of life.


JJ Ross's picture

President Governing With Prayer Too

http://www.nationalprayer.org/
and check out the NASCAR Prayer Car! (I blogged it at Snook as "Who Taught NASCAR Dads to Pray? They're a Quart Low!" The car lost bigtime.)

President Bush at least apparently has a rabbi with him, alongside his cabinet members, some Congressfolk and military figures. Here's the main part of his remarks as released by the White House newswire this morning:

Remarks by President Bush on the National Day of Prayer

WASHINGTON, May 3 /PRNewswire-USNewswire/ -- The following is a
transcript of remarks by President Bush on the National Day of Prayer:
East Room

9:23 A.M. EDT

. . . since the days of our founding, our nation has been called to prayer. That's exactly what our first President did, George Washington. "It's the duty of all nations to acknowledge the providence of
Almighty God, to obey his will, to be grateful for his benefits, and to humbly implore his protection and favor." It's interesting that the first
President said those words.
For two centuries, Americans have answered this call to prayer. We're a prayerful nation. I believe that makes us a strong nation. Each day, millions of our citizens approach our Maker. We pray as congregations in churches and in synagogues, and mosques, and in temples. We welcome people
of all faiths into the United States of America.
We pray as families, around the dinner table, and before we go to sleep. We pray alone in silence and solitude, withdrawing from the world to focus on the eternal, spending time in personal recollection with our Creator.
We pray for many reasons. First, we pray to give thanks for the blessings the Almighty has bestowed upon us. We pray to give thanks. We give thanks for our freedom. We give thanks for the brave men and women who risk their lives to defend it. We give thanks for our families who love and support us. We give thanks for our plenty. We give thanks for our nation.
Second, we pray for the strength to follow God's will in our lives, and for forgiveness when we fail to do so. Through prayer, each of us is reminded that we are fallen creatures in need of mercy, and in seeking the mercy and compassion of a loving God, we grow in mercy and compassion ourselves.
We feel the tug at our souls to reach out to the poor, the elderly, the stranger in distress. And by answering this call to care for our brothers and sisters in need, our hearts grow larger and we enter into a deeper relationship with God.
Third, we pray to acknowledge God's sovereignty in our lives and our complete dependence on Him. This is probably the toughest prayer of all, particularly for those of us in politics. In the humility of prayer we recognize the limits of human strength and human wisdom. We seek the strength and wisdom that comes from above. We ask for the grace to align
our hearts with His, echoing the words of Scripture, "Not my will, but thine be done." We ask the Almighty to remain near to us and guide us in all we do, and when He is near we are ready for all that may come to us.
Finally, we pray to offer petitions, because our Father in heaven knows our cares and our needs. We trust in the promise of a loving God: Ask and
it shall be given to you; seek and ye shall find. Inspired by this confidence we pray that the Almighty will pour out His blessings on those we love. We ask His healing for those who suffer from illness, for those who struggle in life. We ask His comfort for the victims of tragedy, and that the injured may be healed and the fallen may find comfort in the arms
of their Creator. We implore His protection for those who protect us here at home and in far away lands. We pray for the day when His peace will
reign in every nation and in every land until the ends of the earth.
The greatest gift we can offer anyone is the gift of our prayers, because our prayers have power beyond our imagining. The English poet Tennyson wrote, "More things are wrought by prayer than this world dreams
of." Prayer has the power to change lives and to change the course of history.

So on this National Day of Prayer, let us seek the Almighty with confidence and trust, because our Eternal Father inclines his ear to the voice of his children, and answers our needs with love.
May God bless America. (Applause.)

END

9:30 A.M. EDT

SOURCE White House Press Office


Fill up our coffee fund

Visit our sponsors

BlogAds

Visit our sponsors

Who's online

There are currently 3 users and 1932 guests online.

Get our Digestifs du jour

Nibble daily on our brainy goodness with our daily syndication digest. You'll receive an email with a list and links to the previous day's posts.



Powered by FeedBlitz

culturekitchens

The Publisher
Liza Sabater

Daily servings of political dissent
culturekitchen

Grassroots News and
Activism for New Yorkers

Daily Gotham

Feminist Bloggers
Network

BlogSheroes

A new kind of vouyerism
Voogling

Art + Code + Philosophy
Potatoland.blog

Got any dirt, tips, leads or money for us? Then drop us a line or two at editors [at] culturekitchen [dot] com or use our general contact form to reach everybody in the editorial team ASAP.


Member's articles and stories

More stories

Words to live by

"My earlier views of the unsoundness of the Christian scheme of salvation and the human origin of the scriptures, have become clearer and stronger with advancing years and I see no reason for thinking I shall ever change them."


— -- Abraham Lincoln, to Judge J. S. Wakefield, after Willie Lincoln's death (Willie died in 1862) quoted by Joseph Lewis in "Lincoln the Freethinker," also appearing in Remsburg's "Six Historic Americans"