Democrats need to win back the New York State Senate
[Note: This is an abridged version of an earlier post.]
A little known fact : even though New York has had its fair share of Democratic governors, its state government has been in the clutches of the Republicans for 150 years. The only two times the state government was all blue were in 1932 and 1964. Teddy Roosevelt said once that 'the state Senate is constitutionally Republican'; it's not, but it's been reliably Republican since that party was founded in the 1850s.
It's probably the main reason so many groups have come together to support Craig Johnson.
Another little known detail about the Albany political machine : Incumbency has become the product of anti-democratic redistricting shenanigans.
It is outrageous that NYC, the single
largest demographic in the state, does not have proportional representation in Albany. This is because for years Republicans have been able to pass legislation that favors their districts.
Only in New York would you have majority white and Republican districts inflate their demographics by counting their prison population. This is what The New York Times has to say about the practice [Ending the Prison Windfall — New York Times editorial | Prisoners of the Census]:
Inmates are denied the right to vote in all but two states. But state lawmakers treat them as residents of the prisons when drawing legislative maps, to inflate the head count in lightly populated rural areas where prisons are typically built. This creates legislative districts where none would ordinarily be, shifting political influence from the heavily populated urban districts where inmates live.
Once inflated, these towns and counties siphon an outsized portion of state and federal aid. Politicians in districts with prisons sometimes brag openly about the windfall, as they mock “constituents†who are powerless to remove them from office and are packed onto buses and driven hundreds of miles to their real homes the minute
they leave the prison walls.
The repercussions of this particular practice are atrocious : Mostly white and lightly populated areas upstate are being turned into districts on the backs of a prison population that is not only mostly black and latino and poor, but a product of the Rockefeller Laws that have thrown many a first time drug felon into upstate jails with 25-to-life jail sentences. Prisoners of the Census is an apt name for the countless men and women who are being used as electoral pawns.
So when I was asked to lend my hand for this election, the first thing to come to mind was, "Why should I care about a guy in Long island running for a seat in a predominantly white and Republican district?
Well, given Spitzer has made election reform a priority, there is an even more compelling reason to plant the seeds with this election for a Democratic majority in 2008.
With Spitzer's commitment to reform Albany and, among other things, vow to end the atrocious practice of "census farming" through prisos, people have come knocking on his door to lend their support. No wonder the campaign manager of Congressman Keith Ellison is working on this campaign. Yes, the "I am swearing on Jefferson's Koran and don't you try to stop me" Ellison, junior Congressman of Minnesota.
No wonder the list of people involved in this campaign is an amazing mashup of the netroots, grassroots and establishment who's who in New York. The exciting prospect of dismantling the system that has kept a mostly corrupt state government in power is proving to be contagious.
Election Reform | Elections | Fundraising | Gerrymandering | Netroots | Poverty | Race | Albany | Craig Johnson | Democrats | Eliot Spitzer | Long Island | New York
Well...
Since Johnson is pro-choice and pro-stem cell research and O'Connell has a record of being anti-choice and, though she has paid lip service to stem cell research, she has proposed anti-stem cell research legislation. So she can by NO MEANS be considered liberal-leaning, but rather seems to side more with the social extremism of right wing Republicans.
Johnson is in favor of Spitzer's reforms to clean up Albany and make it less dysfunctional. O'Connell supported Spitzer's reforms before she opposed them (her current position).
So Johnson has been consistent and reasonable. O'Connell has flip-flopped all over the place.
Johnson strikes me as a Suozzi-style Democrat. Somewhat too conservative for my tastes, but a genuine conservative Democrat that can be very appealing in that district. Suozzi did some very good things and, although I didn't support him for Governor, I did have some respect for him. Johnson seems cut from a similar cloth and will be an excellent State Senator even if he leans conservative.
This is also a test of who has the better coattails
This race is also about who has the better coattails in that part of the state-- Hillary Clinton or Rudy Guiliani. Since Hillary vs. Rudy could be next year's general election presidential race, it is important for each of them to try and prove they have a strong base. Hence Rudy Guiliani has actively campaigned for Maureen O'Connell and Hillary Clinton for Craig Johnson.
If Rudy Guiliani can't deliver for a republican candidate in a republican district in a republican part of his own state, then you question whether he even has a real base. If Hillary can deliver for a democrat in a republican district/part of the state, it is a sign that she can carry these same areas in the general, even if the opponent is Guiliani. I am sure Team Hillary will be celebrating tonight if Johnson wins 
Well that's a really interesting way of putting it
It really did not occur to me that this could be looked at from the Hillary point of view. Yet, honestly, she hasn't been on the ground campaigning for him as much as Eliot has been.
To me this election has always been about Eliot and nobody else. She really is a marginal player in this picture, as far as raising money and stumping is concerned. She needs to make an appearance today for appearances sake. But this campaign has Eliot's name and presence scrawled all over it.































This race is very interesting
This race is very interesting because it has seemed to cross traditional political boundaries. I heard a radio ad for craig johnson on wcbs claiming that "maureen o'connell and her union interests want to raise you taxes and spend! craig johnson believes taxes are too high. He promises to cut your taxes." Now who sounds like the democrat in that ad? Maureen O'Connell is in fact endorsed by dennis rivera and the good folks at SEIU 1199, as good and reliable liberals as you will find, and they have been running radio ads pointing out that she is/was a nurse and is pro service and pro union. They clearly think Johnson is too moderate/conservative.
Compare those ads and you get the clear impression that the democratic candidate is trying to run to the *right* of the republican candidate! Talk about a strange race. I hope that Spitzer and co. haven't decided that the only way to take back the Senate, because so many of the republican senate seats are on Long Island, is to go to the right. For if you defeat your enemy by becoming your enemy, what have you become?
I hope Craig Johnson wins tonight, but I hate to see local liberals going against SEIU 1199, and I hate to see a Democrat sounding more like a republican than the republican. Such things make you wonder if the price is too high.