One of the most insane expectations to come out of Barack Obama's campaign for Barack Obama's presidency was the misguided notion that the President was going to act as Senator, Congressman, Attorney General and Supreme Court Justice. As Kriss (aka @insanityreport) reminded people this morning, POTUS doesn't write legislation: The President's staff can suggest, poke and prod...but at the end of the day its the 100 member senate & 433 member House that write bills.
Ezra Klein bipartisanship is unlikely to take root at Thursday's summit and Nate Silver seems to agree when he tweets "my gut instinct is more pessimistic than the consensus". Taking a quick look at the summary [PDF DOWNLOAD], am of two minds.
It's not a new "third way out" but a reconciliation bill. It goes after the Ben Nelson FMAP provision by eliminating it and expanding Medicare coverage to all states --trying to make up for one of the biggest mistakes during the Health Care Reform negotiations. Yet, by making no mention of the anti-abortion provision or the public option, it leaves the first one intact and the second one out of this bill.
The only interesting addition is the hot-button government oversight and regulation proposal for a Health Insurance Rate Authority. By calling upon the need for more transparency and fiscal responsibility, it kind of smacks every obstructionist that has invoked those two arguments in their efforts to stop health care reform.
Yet am with Ezra and Nathan : Will this bill really make a difference? My gut instinct hasn't been screaming no since last night. It's been completely revolted since the day universal health care & insurance was not declared as a mission and a right during these negotiations. And as Stupak is still in, immigrants are still discriminated from coverage and the public option is out, there's still no reason to cheer.
Links to Key Provisions in the President’s Proposal:
more this way»







